Are conferences valid sources of information for a paper

image

A conference is somewhat like an open market or bazaar – don’t believe everything the “seller” tells you! However, in some fields (e.g., computer and information science, public administration) major conferences are highly-regarded, the papers are strictly peer-reviewed, and the published proceedings are good sources.

However, in some fields (e.g., computer and information science, public administration) major conferences are highly-regarded, the papers are strictly peer-reviewed

peer-reviewed
Henry Oldenburg (1619–1677) was a German-born British philosopher who is seen as the ‘father’ of modern scientific peer review. A prototype professional peer-review process was recommended in the Ethics of the Physician written by Ishāq ibn ʻAlī al-Ruhāwī (854–931).
https://en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Peer_review

, and the published proceedings are good sources. But since conference papers can have different levels of reliability you have to be careful.May 12, 2022

Full
Answer

How are papers accepted at a conference?

The conference organizers have an editorial team that, as mentioned above, read the research submitted to them before they accept it. The accepted papers are collated into a book or journal known as the conference proceedings.

Does a conference paper count as a scientific publication?

Conference paper is counted as scientific publication. But most of the educational institutions need a peer reviewed indexed journal publication for the promotion purpose. Conference abstract peer review system and journal system is totally different.

Why should you present your research paper at a conference?

When you present your paper at a conference in the topic of your choice, you get an insight into the shortcomings of your research through suggestions and constructive feedbacks. You also get to connect with people of your interest and enhance your research.

Can conference papers be recycled?

@Rafael: Conference papers cannot be recycled: All must report new work and be at least a quantum increase on previous work. If not, which conference owns the copyright?

image


Is a conference paper a credible source?

The most common credible sources are scholarly journals, conference papers and books because these have been peer-reviewed (read and approved for publication by other authors).


Do conferences count as publications?

yes, it’s a publication. It is not exactly the same kind of publication as a journal publication, and depending on the field it may be viewed as less or more important than a journal publication, but it still counts as a publication.


What type of source are conferences?

Conference proceedings are compilations of papers, research, and information presented at conferences. Proceedings are sometimes peer-reviewed and are often the first publication of research that later appears in a scholarly publication (see above!).


Are conferences scholarly sources?

Some fields only review and publish abstracts (e.g., medicine), in some fields conferences are more important than journal publications (e.g., computer science). But as a rule of thumb: a conference is only considered to be peer-reviewed when the full paper is reviewed, and not an (extended) abstract.


Are conference papers published in journals?

The key difference between a journal and a conference paper is that a journal paper is a longer piece of writing which has a definite structure and is published in journals, whereas a conference paper is generally a short and a more precise paper that is presented at a conference.


Is conference paper a research paper?

The key difference between journal and conference paper is that a journal article is a long piece of writing that is published in journals and periodicals, whereas a conference paper is a concise and precise written paper that is presented in research conferences.


Are conference papers peer-reviewed?

The papers presented at a conference have typically been accepted following a review process, however, not all published proceedings are peer reviewed so it is important to assess the quality of the conference. Criteria to consider: Impact of previous papers (through citation counts)


How do you cite a conference proceedings in a paper?

Basic format to reference conference proceedingsAuthor or authors of paper. The surname followed by first initials.Year.Title of paper (in single inverted commas).Editors of conference proceedings.Title of conference proceedings (in italics).Location of conference.Date of Conference (if available)


What sources are not allowed in a research paper?

Unacceptable Sourcesblogs.consultant sites.online encyclopedias (eg. Wikipedia)general online dictionaries.local newspapers.YouTube.


Is conference paper an academic text?

Academic conferences have various formats, but in English, the default mode is a series of panels in which 2–4 scholars deliver presentations and then respond to comments and queries. A conference paper is the text for one of these presentations.


Is conference abstract a publication?

Abstracts of various research papers form the proceedings of various conferences, but these are not considered as publications in real sense.


Do conference papers matter?

A conference paper presentation gives you a platform to interact with people of the same field but journal publication is generally considered superior especially with a good impact factor.


Why are conference papers special?

Knowing your audience is critical for any writing assignment, but conference papers are special because you will be physically interacting with them. Take a look at our handout on audience.


Why do we need a conference paper?

Conference papers can be an effective way to try out new ideas, introduce your work to colleagues, and hone your research questions. Presenting at a conference is a great opportunity for gaining valuable feedback from a community of scholars and for increasing your professional stature in your field. A conference paper is often both …


How to structure a presentation?

How will you structure your presentation? This is an important question, because your presentation format will shape your written document. Some possibilities for your session include: 1 A visual presentation, including software such as PowerPoint or Prezi 2 A paper that you read aloud 3 A roundtable discussion


What is roundtable discussion?

A roundtable discussion. Presentations can be a combination of these styles. For example, you might read a paper aloud while displaying images. Following your paper, you might participate in an informal conversation with your fellow presenters. You will also need to know how long your paper should be.


How long does it take to read a double spaced paper?

A general rule of thumb is that one double-spaced page takes 2-2.5 minutes to read out loud. Thus an 8-10 page, double-spaced paper is often a good fit for a 15-20 minute presentation. Adhere to the time limit. Make sure that your written paper conforms to the presentation constraints.


How to start a research discussion?

You can begin by connecting your research to the audience’s concerns, then share a few examples/case studies from your research, and then, in conclusion, broaden the discussion back out to general issues in the field. Don’t overwhelm or confuse your audience. You should limit the information that you present.


What is the written text of a conference paper?

The written text is only one aspect of the overall conference paper. The other is your presentation. This means that your audience will evaluate both your work and you! So remember to convey the appropriate level of professionalism.


Conference papers

Conference papers are original contributions that were presented at a scientific meeting. In most cases these are not or minimally peer-reviewed. The reason that scientists present a paper at a conference is to inform their peers of their work, especially their new results and ideas and to get feedback.


Examples of conference proceedings

ISPRS 2012 : proceedings of the XXIIth ISPRS congress : Imagining a sustainable future, 25 August – 1 September 2012, Melbourne, Australia. Vol. XXXIX


How to cite a conference paper that has not been published?

To cite a paper that has been presented at a conference but not published, include the author’s name, the date of the conference, the title of the paper (italicized), “Paper presentation” in square brackets, the name and location of the conference, and a URL or DOI if available. Author name, Initials.


What to do if an article has no DOI?

If an article has no DOI, and you accessed it through a database or in print, just omit the DOI. If an article has no DOI, and you accessed it through a website other than a database (for example, the journal’s own website), include a URL linking to the article.


Definition

A conference proceeding is the published record of a conference, congress, symposium, or other meeting sponsored by a society or association, usually but not necessarily including abstracts or reports of papers presented by the participants. When the entire text of the papers presented is included, the result is called transactions.


Reasons to Use

Conference proceeding are a way to engage with leading edge research prior to official journal publication. They may include: findings, innovations, best practices, or new methodology (especially in science & engineering)


How to know if a conference is reputable?

1. Find out which are the established conferences in your field. Your advisor, any professor in the department, or even a senior colleague should be able to help you create a short list of reputable conferences since they have been in the field for years. 2.


What does it mean when a conference is not on the list?

2. If a conference isn’t on that list, it does not necessarily mean that it is not legitimate. There is a possibility that the conference is fairly new or slightly outside your research area. 3. If you happen to come across such conferences, look up the people who are on the organizing committee.


Why is it important to present a paper at a conference?

When you present your paper at a conference in the topic of your choice, you get an insight into the shortcomings of your research through suggestions and constructive feedbacks. You also get to connect with people of your interest and enhance your research.


Why are conference papers important?

Conference paper has a essential importance for communication between the researchers.


What is the review process for conference papers?

The review process for conference papers is typically within a fixed window: everyone submits for a certain deadline, then the review committee (program committee) collaborates to review and discuss papers, then all authors are notified with accept/reject at the same time.


How many papers should I write in a conference?

It is good to begin by contributing in a conference as it boosts the confidence of writing n seeing your work getting published quickly. Ideally after writing 2 or 3 papers in conference start writing some good research paper and getting it published in some average journal and once that is done.


What is a conference paper?

Conference papers refer to articles that are written with the goal of being accepted to a conference: typically an annual (or biannual) venue with a specific scope where you can present your results to the community, usually as an oral presentation, a poster presentation, or a tabled discussion.


Do journals have rolling review?

However, instead of conferences that typically have only accept/reject decisions, journals typically have a rolling review schedule and reviewers can opt to ask the authors for revisions, meaning that there might be multiple review phases (often limited to three, at which stage the paper is rejected/accepted).


Can conference proceedings be promoted?

However, a problem with conference papers is that at many places, papers published as conference proceedings are not accepted for promotion, yet in some places where it is accepted for promotion it is given less credit than a article published in a journal. Cite. 2 Recommendations. 13th Jul, 2018.


Why do researchers publish their research articles in conferences?

Most of the researchers publish their research articles in conference because its a faster way of making the results available. At many places, papers published as conference proceedings are not considered during promotion, on the other hand, at few places it is counted as publications but with less credits.


How long does it take for a professor to submit a high impact finding?

If he submit to journal, at least he need to wait for 1 year until his finding can be available to public.


Why is rigorous review so difficult?

Since rigorous review is a tedious task for even good journals due to lack of sincere reviewers, time constraints, etc., it is very difficult to maintain the quality in conference publications ( there are some exceptions). In conference papers, the scope for correction/revision is very less.


What is an author publishing paper?

An author publishing a paper is assumed to submit a genuine paper, “not published before”. If title, author list and content differ, that is another paper. As about the data in scope of the paper, it can come from someone else’s paper and be reconsidered in the currenrt one, by avoiding plagiarism, of course.


Is publication a legal term?

Publication is a legal means of authoring. But ANY means of publication, including oral, such as conferences, is a way of publishing your ideas. The point here is that some conferences are not indexed by ISI. Actually, in 1987, a conference proceedings volume was published by Elsevier.


Is a conference paper considered a scientific publication?

Conference paper is counted as scientific publication . But most of the educational institutions need a peer reviewed indexed journal publication for the promotion purpose. Conference abstract peer review system and journal system is totally different. Yours Sincerely.


Do conferences have their weight?

Because cost more and provide integration in the specific environment, YES, conferences should have their weight in estimating the scientific value of a work group. Of course, in a professional environment, plagiarized work and shallow research (recherche bidon in French) are identified more quickly also. Cite.


How to find conferences with open calls for papers?

1. Find conferences with open calls for papers. You can use websites, search engines, and professional organizations to search for conferences with open calls for papers. You can search by conference topic or by area of specialization, conference location, etc. Many organizations will specify on their websites exactly how to submit a paper …


How many words should a presentation proposal be?

Presentation proposals are similar to paper abstracts (i.e., 350 words or less), but each conference typically has unique requirements for its proposals. You should read all conference requirements for proposals before you begin writing your proposal.


Can you submit a proposal electronically?

You will probably be submitting your proposal electronically, so be sure that you submit any documents in the form required. If you are accepted to present at a conference, someone from the conference will probably contact you by email.


Can you use a script to present a research paper?

Depending on your field of study, you may use a script to help you present your research, or you may use visual aids like PowerPoint presentations or posters to help you present. You will need to design and practice your presentation ahead of time, making sure to stay within the time frame that the conference has allotted for your presentation.


Is it easier to submit a paper to a conference?

If you already know how to submit a paper for a conference, then you know that submitting papers to conferences is easier than you think, but accepting the amount of rejection you will more than likely face is the hard part. Nevertheless, you should assure yourself ahead of time that being accepted to present at just one conference is worth being …


Why do you notice a lot of other participants presenting unpublished research?

This is because conferences provide a forum to present latest studies that might include preliminary results or proposals. It is usually advisable that the data in your manuscript is more extensive than that presented at the conference.


How much original material should be included in a journal article?

Mention that you are presenting only part of the study and not the content in its entirety. Typically, the journal article should contain at least 30% original material that has not been presented before. The journal might impose some restrictions on how you can present the study at the conference.


What to do if the editor does not agree to the abstract?

If the journal editor does not agree to it, you can inform the conference organizers that your paper on the same topic has already been accepted by a journal and hence you would not want to include the abstract in the conference proceedings.


Can you present a paper that has been published?

However, when presenting a work that has already been published or accepted, there might be some restrictions on how you can reuse the material that has been published/accepted.


Do you need to cite a paper in a presentation?

For instance, you may need to provide citations when including figures from the paper in your presentation, as well as citing any text that is taken directly from what has been published. For many journals, however, you may do so without asking prior permission, so long as you include the appropriate citations.


Can you present unpublished data at a conference?

So presenting unpublished data at a conference should not be a problem.

image

Leave a Comment