Can reporters be banned from wh press conference

image

Although Trump as a political candidate may have a right to refuse news organizations access to his rallies, the First Amendment restricts a president from barring journalists from White House news conferences whose coverage they deem unfavorable.

Full
Answer

Why was CNN’s reporter banned from a White House event?

CNN says one of its reporters was banned from a White House event Wednesday after attempting to ask President Donald Trump a series of questions that were deemed “inappropriate.”

Why did the White House revoke the press passes of journalists?

In what appears to be an unprecedented move, the White House revoked the press passes of a significant chunk of the Washington press corps because they didn’t meet a new standard, according to Washington Post columnist Dana Milbank.

Did the Post’s White House Correspondents fail the new press test?

According to Milbank, virtually the entire press corps failed to meet this new test, including all six of the Post’s White House correspondents. Media outlets then had to apply for exceptions to cover their senior journalists, or settle for six-month passes, which don’t allow as much access.

Should media outlets stop sending their senior journalists to White House briefings?

New outlets and journalists should refuse to do background or off-the-record briefings, Rosen said, and stop repeating the president’s falsehoods. Rosen also argued as early as 2017 that media outlets should stop sending their senior journalists to White House briefings. Does it matter?

image


Are journalists protected?

[…] Article 79 formally states that journalists engaged in dangerous professional missions in zones of armed conflict are civilians within the meaning of Article 50 (1). As such, they enjoy the full scope of protection granted to civilians under international humanitarian law.


Can the public attend press conferences?

Public officials don’t have to hold press conferences, but in doing so they establish what’s known as a limited public forum, a dedication of public space for discussion. The First Amendment provides safeguards for journalists in many disputes over participation in press conferences.


Does freedom of the press only apply to journalists?

Katie Townsend, litigation director of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press: “One of the most commonly misunderstood aspects of the First Amendment is that it only applies to government action. It doesn’t apply to private actors, so a social-media platform, for example, can’t violate the First Amendment.”


Does the press have special rights?

The First Amendment’s language appears to provide a special right for the press, for what has been termed “the Fourth Estate” – the fourth unofficial branch of government that serves as the watchdog of a free society and monitors the official three branches of government.


Why was CNN banned from the White House?

Many veteran journalists are understandably outraged by the development because the move seemed to be in retaliation for stories that the Trump administration didn’t like.


What networks were allowed in Spicer’s office?

Instead, during this incident, NBC, ABC, CBS and FOX News were all allowed in Spicer’s office — and only CNN (of the television networks) was kept out. “This is not the same as when the government selects one television network camera to serve as a pool camera..


Is the gaggle in the White House illegal?

“This is an unacceptable development by the Trump White House,” CNN said in a statement. On top of being unacceptable, the move by the White House may also be illegal and unconstitutional.


Is a press conference a public forum?

Courts have held that a government press conference is a public forum generally open to the media, and any restrictions must be based on reasons other than content,” First Amendment attorney and LawNewz columnist Susan Seager said.


Is it okay for Trump to do a million exclusive interviews with Fox News?

For example, it would be okay for Trump to do a million exclusive interviews with Fox News, and never give one to ABC. However, when it comes to press conferences and briefings that are supposed to be open to the media, the rules are different.


Did the White House have a pool?

A White House spokesperson, in an attempt to defend the move, claimed that the White House “had the pool there so everyone would be represented and get an update from us today.”. However, CNN reports this is not what happened at all.


Did Reince Priebus pressure the FBI?

It’s no secret that over the last few days, CNN has been aggressively reporting a story about how Trump’s Chief of Staff Reince Priebus pressured the FBI to release a statement to squash stories about the Trump/Russia ties. As a result, Trump has strongly criticized the network.


Advertisement

Following a photo op in the Oval Office Wednesday with Trump and European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, Collins called out several questions.


Advertisement

“Mr. President, are you worried about what Michael Cohen is about to say to prosecutors?” Collins continued. “Are you worried what’s on the other tapes, Mr. President? Why has Vladimir Putin not accepted your invitation, Mr. President?”


Advertisement

As today’s radio pooler, I was in the Oval Office with @kaitlancollins, heard her questions, thought they were good and timely ones, and find an official government sanction in response to them an absolute, stunning outrage.


Advertisement

Outrageous of the White House to bar @CNN reporter @kaitlancollins from an open press event because it did not like her questions. A strong leader does not fear questions. A strong democracy does not shield its leader from those who question authority. https://t.co/zmwH0vUZ3A


Why was CNN banned from the White House?

CNN says one of its reporters was banned from a White House event Wednesday after attempting to ask President Donald Trump a series of questions that were deemed “inappropriate.”.


Who is the president of Fox News?

Jay Wallace, the president of Fox News, which is the president’s favorite TV network, also issued a statement blasting the event: “We stand in strong solidarity with CNN for the right to full access for our journalists as part of a free and unfettered press.”.


What did CNN say about Collins’ questions?

CNN said in a statement that Collins’ questions were not inappropriate and they “demand better.”.


Why was Sarah Collins not welcome at the Trump-Cohen feud?

Sanders said Collins was told “she was not welcome” at the event because she “shouted questions and refused to leave despite repeatedly being asked to do so.”. More: Trump-Cohen feud: Taped discussion of payoff to Playboy model triggers open warfare.


Who was the former Fox News co-head?

Collins said she was asked to the office of Bill Shine, the former Fox News co-head and new deputy chief of staff of communications. There she met with Shine and Press Secretary Sarah Sanders, where she was told she wouldn’t be allowed for a news conference between Trump and Juncker. “They said ‘You are dis-invited from …


Did Bernie Sanders take questions from CNN?

I don’t take questions from CNN.”. After the interaction, Sanders posted on Twitter that the reporter “disrespected” Trump and May. Last year, then White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer also famously banned several news organizations, including CNN, from a briefing.


Who was the free lance reporter revoked?

In light of all this, it’s worth noting that just last Monday, a federal judge in New York ruled that the New York Police Department may have acted illegally when it revoked the press credentials of a free lance reporter, Jason B. Nicholas.


Did Sean Spicer ban reporters from a briefing?

Thus the hubbub that ensued when White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer barred some reporters but not others from a briefing last week. The briefing was being conducted on public property by public employees being paid with taxpayer funds and concerned the public’s business.


Is journalism fed from the public trough?

It is also worth noting that journalism is not fed from the public trough. Taxpayers can choose to subscribe to a newspaper or cable channel, but it’s their choice. This, obviously, isn’t true of the services provided by governmental entities.


Do reporters give a damn?

Reporters know this and generally don’t give a damn. Consumers should care though, since reporters are their eyes and ears and their primary job is to report on how taxpayers’ representatives are conducting themselves. This is not just an opinion, it’s the law. The Constitution enshrines the right …


Can reporters be excluded from public events?

Judge J. Paul Oetken wrote that earlier decisions have held that it is impermissible to exclude reporters from public events “in a content-based or arbitrary fashion.”. In other words, public officials can’t exclude reporters whose stories they don’t like while freely admitting those who parrot the prevailing party line.


Why did the White House revoke the press passes?

In what appears to be an unprecedented move, the White House revoked the press passes of a significant chunk of the Washington press corps because they didn’t meet a new standard, according to Washington Post columnist Dana Milbank. Under the new rules, rolled out earlier this year, in order to qualify for the highest level …


Why is the White House briefing important?

Olivier Knox, the president of the White House Correspondents Association, told CNN’s Brian Stelter that the briefing “has both a symbolic and a substantive importance to the White House press corps,” because it shows that “the most powerful political institution in American life is not above being questioned.”.


Why was Acosta’s hard pass revoked?

Later that day, Acosta tried to access the White House in the usual way and was told his “hard pass” had been revoked because of his behavior. Sanders later released a statement saying the CNN reporter’s pass had been withdrawn “until further notice.”. CNN went to court to seek an injunction ordering the White House to return Acosta’s pass, and won.


How did Sandra Bland get her hands on the video?

Justin Ray writes for CJR about how a reporter got his hands on the cellphone video recorded by Sandra Bland when she was pulled over and ordered to get out of the car by an officer wielding a stun gun. Bland was taken into police custody and later discovered hanging in her jail cell three days later. Her death was ruled a suicide, but based on the video her family has asked for the investigation into her arrest and death to be reopened.


Which amendment protected the right to cover the White House?

The media company and a number of other organizations that filed briefs in the case argued that the First Amendment protected the media’s right to cover the White House, and that this right couldn’t be abridged without due process. Judge Timothy Kelly agreed with the latter part of that argument, and said the Trump administration had failed …


Did Disney write down its investment in Vice Media?

Disney Inc. has taken another writedown on its investment in Vice Media, according to The Hollywood Reporter. The entertainment giant recorded a $353 million impairment charge as part of its quarterly results. That comes on top of a previous $157 million writedown it took on its Vice investment in November.


Did the entire press corps meet the new test?

According to Milbank, virtually the entire press corps failed to meet this new test, including all six of the Post’s White House correspondents. Media outlets then had to apply for exceptions to cover their senior journalists, or settle for six-month passes, which don’t allow as much access. The Post applied for and was granted exceptions …

image


A Right to Publish, But Not A ‘Right to Gather?’


Retaliatory Exclusions Can Violate The Law

  • Even if attending a White House event is not a constitutionally guaranteed right, that doesn’t mean the government is free to take it away as a punishment. The government cannot take away even a purely discretionary privilege if the motive is to penalize speech. Even though there is no entitlement to hold a government job, the Supreme Court decided…

See more on theconversation.com


Journalists’ Rights Need Clarifying

  • In a similar case in Maryland, a news organization losta lawsuit against Maryland’s former governor. The Maryland case shows how difficult it can be to prove a retaliation claim. In that 2006 case, a federal appeals court ruledthat Gov. Robert Ehrlich did not violate The Baltimore Sun’s First Amendment rights by directing his administration to stop returning calls or granting i…

See more on theconversation.com

Leave a Comment