Should I publish a new journal article or a conference paper?
A far more compelling argument in favour of a new publication can be made when the journal article is an expanded, more fully developed, or more refined version of the conference paper.
Are papers published as conference proceedings counted as publications?
At many places, papers published as conference proceedings are not considered during promotion, on the other hand, at few places it is counted as publications but with less credits. I appeal to my senior research fellows, kindly give your precious comments over this issue.
How much content is required to publish a conference paper?
Most journals that do consider conference papers follow COPE suggestions and require 40-50% new content overall, written permission from the conference host to publish the paper, and revisions to the work based on the comments/feedback from the conference.
Can I copy the conference paper line by line in Journal?
The conference paper should not be copied line by line in journal paper. Even with a little addition to the contents it can be sent to the journal. So that the readers can get a full idea about your work.
Can conference papers be submitted to journals?
Answer: You can submit the conference paper to a journal. However, you will need to keep the following points in mind. If the full conference paper was previously published in the conference proceedings, it might not be possible to publish it again.
Is conference paper considered a journal?
The key difference between a journal and a conference paper is that a journal paper is a longer piece of writing which has a definite structure and is published in journals, whereas a conference paper is generally a short and a more precise paper that is presented at a conference.
How do you turn a conference paper into a journal article?
The major requirements are that the journal version must have at least 30% new material, the journal version must include a citation to the conference paper, and the journal version must discuss the conference paper and summarize the new material.
Is it better to publish in conference or journal?
A conference paper presentation gives you a platform to interact with people of the same field but journal publication is generally considered superior especially with a good impact factor.
Do conference papers count as publications?
yes, it’s a publication. It is not exactly the same kind of publication as a journal publication, and depending on the field it may be viewed as less or more important than a journal publication, but it still counts as a publication.
Does conference paper have impact factor?
Conference proceedings do not have any impact factor at all. The impact factor is highly dependent on the academic discipline, possibly on the speed with which papers get cited in a field.
Is conference paper an academic text?
Academic conferences have various formats, but in English, the default mode is a series of panels in which 2–4 scholars deliver presentations and then respond to comments and queries. A conference paper is the text for one of these presentations.
What is extended version of conference paper?
A paper that often accepted in the conference; and there is an opportunity to extend to be published in a journal but after developing almost over %50 from the original one.
How can I improve my journal article?
10 tips to improve your research articles1) Find your message. … 2) Know your audience. … 3) Build a storyline. … 4) Keep facts and ideas where they belong. … 5) Build modules. … 6) Do not assume knowledge but do not state the obvious. … 7) Do not repeat information. … 8) Write clearly, concisely and elegantly.More items…•
Is IEEE Xplore a journal?
The IEEE Xplore digital library is your gateway to trusted research—journals, conferences, standards, eBooks, and educational courses—with more than 5 million documents to help you fuel imagination, build from previous research, and inspire new ideas.
Is IEEE Xplore prestigious?
Global Prestige The premier source for technical content, IEEE Xplore has over 5 million documents and provides over 8 million downloads each month. IEEE is also the most cited publisher in US and European new technology patents—with over 3x more than any other publisher.
Is IEEE a good publisher?
IEEE is a top publisher for engineering sciences.  All of their publications are highly respected in the scientific community both in academia and industry, as well as government. The IEEE journals are also highly ranked by impact factor.
Why are duplicate papers problematic?
Another reason why so-called ‘duplicate’ publications are problematic is that they can distort the scholarly record. This is because they make it unclear that two or more papers (i.e., the conference presentation and the subsequent paper) refer to the same study. Readers might be left with the impression that the findings of the journal article confirm those reported in the conference, when in fact it is the same dataset that is being described twice. In some disciplines, most notably medicine, such distortion could have serious consequences if, for example, the same dataset were to be included several times in a meta-analysis that draws on multiple articles. In language education, and probably most of the Humanities and Social Sciences as well, implications are usually not quite so dire. Still, distorting the scholarly record is taken seriously, and it leads to article retractions, which are very public and very embarrassing for everyone involved.
How to show the origin of an article?
A common way to show the origin of the article is by inserting a footnote or endnote somewhere in the text (e.g., “The findings reported in this article were originally presented at….” ). It is also good practice to draw the journal editor’s attention to the previous publication, and explain what —if any— changes have been made. This allows them to make their own decision about whether the paper merits further consideration, plus they can often offer helpful suggestions about how to deal with the situation.
What is the problem with self plagiarism?
The main problem here is self-plagiarism, i.e., re-publishing a text you wrote in the past, and passing it off as something new. Unlike actual plagiarism, self-plagiarism does not involve ‘stealing’ words or ideas, but it is still an act of academic deception. Readers, who may spend money and time to access an author’s work, do so because they implicitly expect that they have never read this work before, and self-plagiarism violates their trust ( How would you feel if you bought a detective novel, only to find that it had the same plot as the author’s previous work, along with identical chunks of text? ).
Can you publish a conference paper as a journal article?
A final thing to consider when thinking about publishing a presentation as a journal article is whether the new publication adds to the body of scholarly knowledge. Sometimes (but not very often), it may actually be useful to re-publish a conference paper as a journal article with no changes at all. This may be the case with obscure or regional conferences, or conferences that only publish their proceedings in a limited number of print volumes. In such a case, an argument could be made that the new publication helps to make the findings available to a wider readership, although institutional and disciplinary repositories are usually a better alternative (Here’s a list of such repositories, in case you’re interested).
Do conference papers have to be shorter than journal articles?
At minimum, the text will have to be adjusted to meet the needs of the journal’s readership, and any changes that highlight different aspects of the study may be of scholarly value. Another thing to remember is that conference papers tend to be shorter and more focused than journal articles.
Do academic conferences have proceedings?
Many academic conferences nowadays have their proceedings published, even if the ‘proceedings’ only exist as a .pdf file that lives briefly online at the conference website. When this happens, copyright of the papers that are included in the proceedings normally passes from the author (s) to the conference organisers.
Can a journal article be a conference presentation?
The short answer to this question is ‘yes’. In language education, and in many other disciplines, it is quite common for journal articles to begin their life as conference presentations ( and if you scroll all the way to the bottom of this post, you can find out more about how to expand a conference paper to a journal article ). But before you do any of that, there are three things that you should consider.
Popular Answers (1)
Conferences sometimes public a “proceedings book” in which the conference papers are published.
All Answers (16)
Yes you can. Academic journals regularly accept and publish original and unpublished articles, which have not been published in any other way. In the case of a conference paper, the case may be different. I explain.
Similar questions and discussions
If research is published in conference proceedings, can it still be published in journals?
Why do you present a preliminary analysis at a conference?
The purpose of presenting your research at a conference is to inform people about your study and get feedback from them to improve your methodology.
How to improve the chances of a manuscript being accepted?
Improve the chances of your manuscript’s acceptance by learning how to prepare a manuscript for journal submission and handle the peer review process. Subscribe and get curated content that will give impetus to your research paper.
When will abstracts get accepted in SCI?
If I submit my abstract now to the Society, develop it into a paper soon after, and submit it to an SCI journal, it might get accepted by the journal before October. However, there is a higher possibility of the paper getting accepted by the journal after October. Here are my questions. 1.
Can you present a published article at a conference?
It is also acceptable to present your published work at a conference. However, in this case, it is generally considered good practice to cite your published article and provide a link at the end of the presentation if it is avilable online. 1.You can submit your conference abstract to the society and submit the full-fledged paper …
Can you publish a conference paper in a journal?
So, it is okay to develop a previously published conference paper into a full-length manuscript and publish it in a journal later on. This is an acceptable practice, provided you clearly disclose the conference paper and include at least 30% new material in the journal paper.
Can you present a paper at a conference?
2. It is also fine to present at the conference, write the paper after the presentation and then submit it to the journal. In fact, this might work better for you because you will be able to incorporate the feedback that you receive at the conference in your paper.
Can you submit an abstract to a conference?
1.You can submit your conference abstract to the society and submit the full-fledged paper to an SCI journal around the same time. However, it is best inform the editor about this and ask whether it is fine to publish the abstract as part of the conference proceedings. If the journal editor is not okay with publishing the abstract, you can still make your presentation, but inform the conference organizers that you would not want it to be a part of the conference proceedings.
Why do researchers publish their research articles in conferences?
Most of the researchers publish their research articles in conference because its a faster way of making the results available. At many places, papers published as conference proceedings are not considered during promotion, on the other hand, at few places it is counted as publications but with less credits.
Why are conference papers not accepted for promotion?
However, a problem with conference papers is that at many places, papers published as conference proceedings are not accepted for promotion, yet in some places where it is accepted for promotion it is given less credit than a article published in a journal.
How much of a manuscript should be new?
Generally, it is required that your manuscript is improved based on the feedback of the conference review process and on the discussion at the conference, a (computer science) rule of thumb is that at least 30% of the material should be new and the exposition improved. In most fields conference papers are views as preliminary results open …
What is the scope of acceptance in a conference?
Generally the scope for acceptance in a conference and journal are different. The general practice is to present the preliminary results in a conference. Since it is presented in front of knowledgeable crowd who are familiar with the subject get some inputs about your study, discussion and conclusion.
Can a research paper be published in both scientific journals and proceedings?
Thanks a lot for sharing this question.From my perspective, I think that the same research paper can be published in both proceedings and scientific journals, taking into account that the paper published in journal should be an extension of the research presented at the Conference based on the observations and comments from experts who attend your presentation and gave a useful feedback to improve/enhance the proposed methodology. These suggestions can be used in a journal paper to give better results. In this case, you will add a positive value to your upcoming work instead of repeating the same exact work.
Is a full manuscript published online?
As a usual practice, full manuscripts for oral presentation are published online as part of the proceedings journal/book of abstracts. Can we still submit the same paper to are reputable journal for publication?
Can a conference paper be published in a journal?
Yes, conference paper may be published in any journal if the data and methodology are same but the interpretation is different. If conference paper is published in conference proceedings as a full paper then you can not publish the that paper as copy paste style. As long as you modify it, yes you can.
What is a conference paper?
If you’re a PhD student, you’ll want to attend conferences as often as possible. You’ll have numerous opportunities to network with researchers in your field, and get feedback on your work. Getting your work published in conference details and proceedings is another advantage.
Submit Conference Paper to Journal
Your conference paper is typically limited to publication within the conference proceedings and documentation. Sometimes, if your work is deemed exceptional, you may be invited to publish in a research journal, along with other conference participants. So, a conference paper might be submitted to a journal as a part of the conference itself.
How to Write a Conference Paper Proposal
The first thing to remember is that your conference paper proposal is a stand-alone document. The proposal is just that – a proposal to present your information and paper at a conference. Your audience is very specific in that it is written for the selection committee for the conference that you would like to present at.
How to Submit a Paper to a Conference
First, find a conference that is looking for submissions. You can do this by using search engines like Google, or utilizing contacts and connections you might have within any professional organizations that you belong to.
Does The New Paper Infringe Copyright?
Does The New Paper Deceive Readers?
The second issue to consider is academic honesty. The main problem here is self-plagiarism, i.e., re-publishing a text you wrote in the past, and passing it off as something new. Unlike actual plagiarism, self-plagiarism does not involve ‘stealing’ words or ideas, but it is still an act of academic deception. Readers, who may spend money and time to access an author’s work, do s…
Does The New Paper Add Value to The Scholarly Record?
A final thing to consider when thinking about publishing a presentation as a journal article is whether the new publication adds to the body of scholarly knowledge. Sometimes (but not very often), it may actually be useful to re-publish a conference paper as a journal article with no changes at all. This may be the case with obscure or regional con…
Coming back to the original question: Provided the new submission passes the tests of legality, ethics and value, it is perfectly fine to publish a conference presentation as an article. Before you go:If you landed on this page because you’re planning to write an article, I hope that you found this post helpful and I wish you all the best with your publishing endeavours. For some ideas about p…