How to review a conference


Improving your conference peer-review process

  • Invite enough reviewers. Overloading reviewers is one sure way to annoy them. And unhappy reviewers tend to withdraw…
  • Set realistic deadlines. Your members are busy people. One great way to get on their bad side is to set up review…
  • Craft a straightforward reviewer experience. A clear and straightforward revieiwing…


Can I be reviewer of the conference papers that I attend?

Some of journal editors, book editors and many conference editors organize mutual review process between paper contributors. The idea of this advice is that you can be reviewer of the conference papers that you attend.

What to do after the event/conference?

After the event/conference is over, it’s time to regroup. A survey conducted after the conference highlights the high and low points of the entire conference. It also gives you an opportunity to re-engage with the attendees and ask for their insights on the conference as a whole.

Can I send an abstract of a review paper to a conference?

Bookmark this question. Show activity on this post. I sent an abstract of a review paper for oral presentation to a conference, and it was accepted. The presentation will be about the most important developments and contributions made in the last decade on my specific area of research.

How do you write a conference report?

Including the names of the speakers on your report will help recognize the authority they hold in discussing their topics. 2. Include the main objective of the conference The conference is conducted to achieve a certain goal or objective.


How do you write a review for a conference paper?

“Reviewing the paper” means reading to a level that you understand what the authors did, why it’s interesting, and why it’s important. As part of your review, you should note these things. And you should accept or reject the paper based on whether you think the *contribution* is significant enough.

What is a conference review?

The reviews help the Executive Committee select which papers to accept and reject. Additionally, your reviews help the authors of papers make their papers and presentations stronger. Finally, your suggestions help the Program Chairs select the outstanding papers.

How do you evaluate the quality of a conference?

How to identify quality Academic conferencesThe Quality of papers presented in conference and reviewing process. … Good keynote speakers who speak much relevant to the conference. … Serving the purpose and objective of the conference. … Having strong Index Journals and publications.More items…•

How do you review a conference abstract?

Abstract Review GuidelinesIs the question or issue clearly stated?Is the significance of the work clearly stated? … If relevant, are the method, data collection, and analysis procedures well-designed and appropriate to the question addressed?Is the conceptual framework coherent? … Is the work original?More items…

What is review process in conference publication?

Peer review is a process in which a scientific paper is evaluated by a group of experts in the same field to make sure it meets the necessary standards for acceptance and publication.

How do you know if a conference is peer-reviewed?

Some of these papers will go on to be published in peer-reviewed journals, but others will not. You can tell that what you have found is a conference paper if, instead of a journal title, a conference or meeting title is listed as the publisher. You will also find Conference session or Poster presentation in brackets.

How do you evaluate a journal conference magazine?

Evaluating Journals & ConferencesCaliber of the research published: Read over a few articles to assess the quality and rigor of the research reported.Aims & scope statement – does it adequately describe the journal’s objectives and help you determine if you should submit your work to it?More items…•

How do I apply for a conference in Canada?

A person who is coming to Canada to attend a conference needs authorization to come to Canada, such as an eTA or visitor’s visa. No work permit is required. U.S. citizens coming from the U.S. can get authorization at the border. Everyone else will need either an eTA or visitor’s visa.

How do you present a literature review in a conference?

Presenting Literature Review in the Introduction and Discussion SectionsIntroduce the topic.Establish the significance of the study.Provide an overview of the relevant literature.Establish a context for the study using the literature.Identify knowledge gaps.Illustrate how the study will advance knowledge on the topic.

How do you write an abstract for a conference example?

Quick TipsComply. Diligently follow all abstract style and formatting guidelines. … Be Concise. With a 250-500 word limit, write only what is necessary, avoiding wordiness. … Be Clear. Plan your abstract carefully before writing it. … Be Clean. Revise and edit your abstract to ensure that its final presentation is error free.

How do you judge an abstract?

Overall quality/presentation Is the background presented in a logical manner leading to the question? Are the question and answer stated clearly? Is the question appropriate? Are the conclusions reasonable given the results?

Are conference papers included in systematic review?

While identifying and cataloging unpublished studies from conference proceedings is generally recognized as a good practice during systematic reviews, controversy remains whether to include study results that are reported in conference abstracts. Existing guidelines provide conflicting recommendations.

Are conference abstracts considered publications?

Abstracts of various research papers form the proceedings of various conferences, but these are not considered as publications in real sense.

How do you present a literature review in a conference?

Presenting Literature Review in the Introduction and Discussion SectionsIntroduce the topic.Establish the significance of the study.Provide an overview of the relevant literature.Establish a context for the study using the literature.Identify knowledge gaps.Illustrate how the study will advance knowledge on the topic.

Can I use conference paper in literature review?

Answer: Conferences do not usually accept literature review manuscripts or review articles for publishing in their conference proceedings.

Most recent answer

To review a paper, it is advisable to read some available reviews in open public domain. Even comments on published and unpublished papers can help to understand the review mechanism.

Popular Answers (1)

Nowadays you have number of new and not yet established publishers that invite reviewers and editors for their international peer-reviewed open access journals. I received plenty of such invitations. Honestly, I ignore them because I have a more or less fixed lists of journals that I regularly receive invitations from for paper review.

All Answers (10)

If you mean reviewing academic papers, perhaps you should start with student journals. Some directories to consider – check journal announcements if they are looking for reviewers:

Similar questions and discussions

If research is published in conference proceedings, can it still be published in journals?

How many reviewers are needed for SITE?

SITE conference submissions are subject to a double-blind peer review process by a minimum of three reviewers. Reviewers are members the conference’s international Program Committee of experts in fields specifically matching the conference topics.

What does AACE do when a paper is rejected?

Authors whose papers are rejected have the opportunity to submit short papers for the second call for papers.

Do case studies need references?

Major theoretical studies should have larger reference lists. Small case studies might only need references to their theoretical underpinnings and one or two related studies. Length of Paper – Conference papers have particular limits and benefits. You should consider whether the ideas are appropriate for the length.


Leave a Comment